Even if it did, it is still valid today in a very real sense as every Palestinian alive identifies as such.
Israel at war
- Thread starter Butler1000
- Start date
we already agreed that it is real at least as long as the conflict is real (after which it may still be real but no one will really give a shit).
Meanwhile you are giving out labels rather generously. Who is “every Palestinian alive”? Are Arab citizens of israel Palestinians? They sure as hell live between the river and the sea and they ain’t Jews. But they are not in a hurry to move to gaza or West Bank.
Here’s an interesting poll: 502 Arab citizens of Israel above the age of 18 were asked about who should run Gaza the day after the war, most respondents (58.5%) said that the administration should be in the hands of Palestinians. Of those, 24.4% said they would prefer local bodies from Gaza to manage the Strip, followed by 19.4% who said it should be governed by the Palestinian Authority, and 14.7% said by Hamas.
Conversely, 34.4% of respondents said that an external non-Palestinian body should govern the coastal enclave. Of those, 19.4% opted for an international force, 8.4% chose Israel and 6.5% favored a coalition of Arab states.
So their identity and love for Palestine is kinda all over the place as one would expect.
Same with Israelis, same with Canadians. Identity may exist but a lot of people won’t identify as you may expect. Every nation have heroes and traitors and everyone in between.
Many Arab citizens of Israel consider themselves Palestinian by nationality and Israeli by citizenship. There are also those that dont use the Palestinian label. This is a very political issue because anyone who reports has a political agenda.
If you ask people in Gaza or the West Bank, they overwhelmingly consider themselves Palestinian.
You're breaking new heights (or new lows) even by your "standards", Adolf
Israel and Netanyahu have charges pending at the ICC and ICJ for genocide and extermination.
That is the same crime as the nazis.
Those are the legal standards and Israel and nazis are now forever in the same conversations about genocide.
You just chose to side with genocide and nazis.
You moved the goal posts over there now?
Holy fuck, your world gets tinier every day.
Even with Israel fighting to take even a bit of Lebanon the world reaction is deafening.
Francesca Albanese LOL
UN Watch Files Proceedings to Remove UN's Hamas Apologist Francesca Albanese — Full Text of Draft Resolution - UN Watch
GENEVA, July 2, 2024 — UN Watch announced that today it has filed proceedings with the United Nations to remove Francesca Albanese. In a draft resolution submitted today to the President of the Human Rights Council (see text below), executive director Hillel Neuer called on the 47-nation body to...
unwatch.org
The Jordanian royalty has, but the population has not.
The King may lose his kingdom.
Why did you not say so instead of:
"It was a name on a map in a textbook in the UK.
That's why the British used it. It had no reality for the inhabitants."
Francesca Albanese LOL
UN Watch Files Proceedings to Remove UN's Hamas Apologist Francesca Albanese — Full Text of Draft Resolution - UN Watch
GENEVA, July 2, 2024 — UN Watch announced that today it has filed proceedings with the United Nations to remove Francesca Albanese. In a draft resolution submitted today to the President of the Human Rights Council (see text below), executive director Hillel Neuer called on the 47-nation body to...unwatch.org
UN Watch is Israeli propaganda.
try again